We were asked, on Thursday, what sense would you give up if you had to choose?
I really don't know. So lets use the process of illumination:
Sight: No, it's to important, we rely on this sense the most so it would have the most impact of absence. Also, I don't know what I would do without being able to see the beauty in this world.
Hearing: Again, no. Hearing is one of the most important senses to me, I am a musician and I don't know what I would do without music in my life. I have seen an old woman weep after being able to 'hear' through a balloon pressed against a piano for the first time in 20 years. From this reaction I can see what a profound loss it can be and don not want to have to go through that myself.
Touch: Touch is such a profoundly important sense to have, it tells us the most about what is going on in our immediate surroundings, temperature, how bad wounds are, whether our feet are touching the ground or not! I have had a numbing cream placed on my hands before and the feeling is horrible, to have that all the time everywhere would be horrible.
Taste & Smell: These two are lumped together because if you lose one you lose half of the other. This is shown in that half of the taste is the smell. If you lost your smell you wouldn't be able to taste a lot of the tastiest foods. The same is with taste. If you lost taste, you would be able to smell delectable goods but not taste them!
All-in-all, I would rather not have to pick between these, I would take a randomised pick, even at the risk of losing sight or hearing. Ideally, you would have this disability from birth and so wouldn't know any better and wouldn't have to experience the loss which comes with losing the sense part-way through your life.