Monday, 10 March 2014

Knowledge Issue: What defines a country?

That's a good question. What does define a country? If you were to ask governments they would tell you the locations of the said country's boarders, in New Zealand that is not very disputable, but in place like Europe and Africa, that is potentially up for debate. For instance, in Ukraine, the Russian speaking Ukrainians would argue that they are a part of Russia, the Ukrainian government argues that the Crimea is rightfully Ukrainian ever since it was gifted to Ukraine. Moscow argues that they can rightfully take it back. A lot of this issue seems to stem from when the Crimea was gifted to Ukraine by some Russian dictator. But what gives him the authority to determine the nationality of the people living in the Crimea?
Which leads into, Is it the people or the land that determines the country? Another potential area for debate is Tokelau, a country gifted by the Allies to New Zealand after WWII. Are they now Tokelauan or Kiwi? Again are we, as New Zealanders, New Zealanders or Brits of the Commonwealth? You can't really say.
Back in Roman times country borders hopped around all over the place as people on the losing side changed to the apparent winning side. Now our borders are pretty concrete, but people aren't. In the case of Ukraine, the Russians living in the Crimea truly believe that they are a part of Russia and they form a majority of the Crimean population, is it not their right to have that recognised officially? The long-dead dictator who determined their nationality simply wrote it down, he didn't change the people. A country is not a country without its people. But at the same time, we don't recognise gypsy camps as separate people, so a country cannot be a country without its land and proposed borders. Again it's a case of majority rules. Under that, Pakistan became a separate country to India, and therefore, the Crimea is a part of Russia.

1 comment:

  1. Are you able to line up arguments on each side of the debate? Can you see it from both sides? What would be a way to arrive at the fairest, most ethical answer to this question? Is it even possible?

    It would have been good to see you explore specific groups of reasons, categorised, around why one might decide one way or the other?

    A good bit of thinking going on here.

    ReplyDelete